Fan Fiction Wonderings

A few weeks ago, I watched the season finale of the X-Files.  As I have mentioned before, I adore the show but I’m not sure about the last episode.  Apparently, I am not alone in being perplexed by the ending as I have seen a number of comments about it on social media.  After the episode, I did what many others did, I sought out fan fiction.  Could fans of the show provide a different, more understandable, more enjoyable ending?  I wondered.  Needless to say, the number of stories that popped up were many.  As I began to read some, I pondered the role of fan fiction in fandom and then specifically in our fandom.

It seems to me that fanfic for TV shows, movies and books serves an important function.  It adds to the story, in some way.  Maybe these stories extend the story beyond what was shown either after it ends or through a potential missing scene.  Of course, some readers prefer the alternate universe in which the characters are placed in a different context.  I can understand all of that and have read my fair share, especially when I was a big Roswell fan.

What about the work of fanfic in a fandom like ours?  We are not fans of made up characters.  No, the subjects of our fandom are real people.  Does that make a difference?  Looking at the purpose of fanfic in those other genres, could they be applied here?  Could authors extend the Duran story by adding to an unknown future or filling in a period or episode that is unknown to us?  I’m sure that writers could.  Could they place the subjects into different contexts?  Again, that seems logical.

What interests me is that while I have enjoyed these fan created stories when thinking about TV shows like Roswell and X-Files, I never grabbed onto fanfic within my Duran fandom.  Why is that?  I wonder if it has to do with the fact that the focus on the fandom is real people.  Yet, I can read historical fiction and enjoy it.  Those works of fiction are often about real people and events.  I’m not sure.    Maybe it feels different because I have seen the band members in person and for me, that makes it feel different for me.  Perhaps, it is because I have spent so many years researching fandom and thinking about this fandom in an academic sense that I have lost any ability to enjoy this aspect.

Don’t get me wrong here.  I’m not criticizing fanfic readers or writers within our fan community.  No, I’m trying to understand myself because it feels like a weird hang up that I have.  So, those of you who read or write Duran related fanfic, why does it work for you?  What makes you like it?  I would love to hear some good reasons to push me to try it again.

-A

4 thoughts on “Fan Fiction Wonderings”

  1. I am a lover of fan fiction.
    It works for me in the way it takes me mentally away from what I do not like off reality, off the real world.
    I mean: if I do not like facts and decisions taken by my music hero’s label or managers, I go read my fave fiction where none of those things happens and I feel better.

    1. I think you hit on one of the reasons his fanfic exists.I think also we wish we knew more about the guys in their private lives offstage.I like the ones in which they are new to the business and what ‘might have’ happened.

  2. This blog really resonated with me. I have read and written fanfic in so many fandoms. I learned of the Duran fic and promptly went in search of it.And it feels a little odd. I think the point that they are real, not fictional is the source. But a lot of it is so creative, and clearly the product of the love felt for the guys. I’d say do look at some and just enjoy it as an ‘alternate universe’ Some of it as a very alternate universe. I have started trying to write one also just for fun. No, I’m not finding it as easy as I’d thought.

    1. I definitely might try to check out some over the summer. If you finish yours, let me know. I would love to read it. -A

We (Amanda and Rhonda) appreciate discussion and differences of opinion. We respectfully ask that you fully read the blog before bitching us out. If you're only here to take us down a notch, note that we moderate replies (meaning we're not printing rude comments). Thanks a bunch!